A place to discuss all things nerdy. So far mainly movie reviews, but looking to expand further into geek culture and media. The Late Nite Scholar is a born geek who married a geek and raises geek offspring, and specializes in movies, gaming, comics, books, and history. So come in and enjoy, leave your thoughts and let us know how you feel about the posts, the items we discuss, or anything else you want to talk about within our beloved genre.
Thursday, 21 September 2017
The Mummy Spoiler Free Review
Well, we’re back again with another movie review. Today we’re
going to look at an interesting one: the first (second? third?) revival of the
Universal Monsters and the beginning of their own, new cinematic universe. I’m
talking of course about, The Mummy. Now there’s been a lot of really bad
buzz about this one, so we decided to see what all the fuss was about. As
usual, no spoilers ahead.
I’ll be totally honest, I kind of expected this to be a hate-watch.
In fact, we came prepared, just in case. I even tried something new for the
occasion.
Not bad, but really sweet. Also, why do I always get pink wine for these kind of movies? |
I was willing to give this movie the shot, the benefit of
the doubt, even. That is despite how dumb the trailers looked. Because trailers
can be deceiving. It was kind of a ‘hope for the best but prepare for the worst’
kind of scenario. And well, I’m kind of glad I did. I’m going to come right out
and say it: this movie is dumb. Not the dumb fun way that I actually
tend to really enjoy, but the flopping over like a disgruntled teenager while
whining ‘this is duuuuumb’ kind of way.
Laaaaame.... |
Let’s examine this further by breaking down the exact issues
with this movie.
-Tom Cruise is horribly miscast and phoning it in. Watching this
movie, you can tell that this role was written for a younger actor (Russell
Crowe even says ‘you are a younger man’. Cruise is 2 years older than
Crowe). So much of it just doesn’t add up with Cruise as the lead. That’s not
the only reason he’s miscast, though. His character is clearly supposed to be a
‘dashing rogue’, Han Solo-ish type and Tom Cruise cannot sell that, nor
can he deliver a one-liner or quip that lands. He’s an annoying asshole with none
of the charm this character needs, especially with his buddy Vale, played by a
grating Jake Johnson who’s worse than he was in Jurassic World. They
obviously cast Cruise for the star power, but he is completely wrong for this
role.
-Annabelle Wallis’ character, Jenny. First off, her and Tom
Cruise have exactly zero chemistry on screen. Their ‘romance’ arc is totally
forced, unearned, and basically out of nowhere. She’s also the worst
character, and that isn’t the fault of the actress. She has nothing to do but
spout exposition, be a damsel in distress, and have cringe-worthy conversations
about how she thinks Cruise’s character ‘is a good man’. I don’t know who she’s
trying to convince more, her or us. It was a conversation that was so trite,
forced, and cheesy that I rolled my eyes so hard I’m pretty sure I saw my own
brain. If I wanted to watch a movie about lost ancient treasures with a
loveable rogue and a useless blonde, I’ll go watch Temple of Doom,
because that one’s actually enjoyable.
damn rights |
-Ahmanet’s timeline. This one really gets under my skin, and
that’s putting it mildly. We have three different dates for Ahmanet, each
corresponding to very different periods in history. In trailer 2, Jenny
says that the tomb has been buried for 2,000 years. That would put Ahmanet in
the Roman period and long after the end of the native Egyptian pharaohs. Okay,
so maybe that was a flub on the trailers’ part, right? Both the UniversalMonsters Wiki and Wikipedia itself say that Ahmanet is from the New Kingdom
era, or around 3,000 years ago. That date actually makes sense given what we
see of her in the flashbacks. This would have been peak Pharaonic Egypt and
that would have worked great. In the movie itself, Jenny says twice that
Ahmanet (and her sarcophagus) are 5,000 years old. That would put her way back
in the First Dynasty (New Kingdom was 18-20th Dynasties), not long
after the unification of Upper and Lower Egypt. That would also mean that those
lovely, recognizable pyramids in the background of the flashbacks wouldn’t be
there, as they wouldn’t be built until the Fourth Dynasty. So… get your dates
right, guys. Seriously.
-Stupid archaeology. This kind of goes along with my last
point about the timeline, but as someone trained in the field, I can’t let this
go. Jenny is a terrible archaeologist. They pull out the sarcophagus, seemingly
taking nary a provenance, or you know, contacting the government of the
country they’re in before they just haul it away. And what about all the
rest of the stuff down there? Are they just going to leave it there? They pull
up the sarcophagus with two little straps tied around it and then the helicopter
flies away, swinging it through the air like it’s a carnival ride. Two straps
and not even a blanket or a tarp to protect it as its sails through the air and
the blowing sand.
Ahmanet's gonna need some Gravol |
This is beside the fact that while the stuff in the tomb
looks relatively Egyptian, Ahmanet’s sarcophagus doesn’t look Egyptian at all.
I suppose they wanted a ‘horror’ or ‘monster’ theme with that, but it looks
dumb and out of place. Oh, and you can’t ‘mummify someone alive’. That’s not
how it works guys. You can bury someone alive, and I suppose you can start mummifying someone alive, but they aren’t going to stay that way for
very long. Again, just a dumb line that stuck out to me.
-Sexist crap. Okay, just a quick point on this. There are
some gross shots of the female characters in this film. There’s
one part where Jenny reaches up to get something while in the foreground and
you’re basically looking down her exposed stomach and pretty much down her
pants. Yuck. She also ends up in the water in a white t-shirt. Also yuck. This
is added on top of how Jenny is basically just a useless, damsel character.
This movie even has a butt-focused shot of the Mummy herself! And it would have
been so much cooler if Ahmanet herself wasn’t so interested in bringing Set into
our world, but rather was consolidating her power for herself and her own rule.
Wasn’t that her whole plan in the first place? I’m not even going to go into
something said at the end after Cruise has rescued Jenny that was said (and
done) so much better in a movie that came out earlier in the summer. I actually
had to pause the movie because I was so angry about it and how it cheapened
that line. I don’t want to say what it was, because spoilers, but it was the
same thing a male character said to a female one in a much better movie and
with much more emotional impact. (If you really want to know, I can post it in
the comments lol)
-Exposition, aka, let me tell you a story. Honestly, there
are so many scenes where everything just stops and one character begins telling
another what’s going on or what we need to know at that given moment. The film
literally begins and ends with an exposition dump. It is ‘tell, not show’
to the nth degree, and it gets pretty tiresome. In fact, one exposition scene
is telling us about things that we just had seen a few minutes ago on
screen. It just grinds everything to a halt to try and flesh out this universe
that they’re building, but it really affects the overall pacing. And yet with
all this exposition, there are things that don’t get explained! The double iris
thing, the Templars and the dagger, why she’s buried in Mesopotamia (Iraq)
instead of Egypt, and so on.
-Bad CG. It’s not very good, need I say more? Much like Tom
Cruise’s performance, it felt like they weren’t even trying.
Alright, I’m not going to end this off on such a negative
note. There were a couple of positives. Let’s lighten things up and have a look
at them.
-Russell Crowe as Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde. You can tell he’s
having fun with this, and truthfully he’s one of the best parts of the movie. Think
of him as the Dark Universe’s Nick Fury.
I'm here to speak to you about the Monster Initiative.... |
The differences in his character
between the two personalities was pretty cool, even if most of what he does is
exposition.
-The plane crash/ zero grav stunt. I’ll give credit where
credit is due, that stunt was pretty cool. The fact that they did so much of it
practically is really impressive. Tom Cruise may not have fit well with this
movie, but at least you get here what he does in his other films: him doing something
completely nuts and doing it for real.
-At one point when the Mummy is bearing down on our main
characters, my other half busts into Hall and Oates’ ‘Maneater’. It was
hilarious, out of left field, and sorely needed at that point.
So there it is, guys. This really was not a good movie. I’d
say just stick with the Brendan Fraser ones, or the original Universal Monsters
films. It’s really not worth your time, and will in several places remind you
of other, better films that you could be watching instead. Skip it.
3/10
Tuesday, 5 September 2017
Star Wars: Episode IX Loses Director!
So this is what I come home to. Get home from work and this video pops up in my subscriptions and the news all over my Twitter feed. Colin Trevorrow and Disney have parted ways and he will no longer direct Star Wars Episode IX, slated for release in May 2019.
This was the statement released by Lucasfilm:
"Lucasfilm and Colin Trevorrow have mutually chosen to part ways on Star Wars: Episode IX. Colin has been a wonderful collaborator throughout the development process but we have all come to the conclusion that our visions for the project differ. We wish Colin the best and will be sharing more information about the film soon."
So, that happened. What does this mean for the future of the film? No idea at this point, given this is all we know at the moment. Trevorrow had originally co-written the script as well, which was previously announced that another writer had been brought in to do a rewrite. I'm sure we'll here more on this later on as more information us released by the parties involved.
I guess the question now is, who is going to step in and take over? There's of course lots of speculation and fan suggestion and whatnot happening already. A predominant theory so far is that Episode VIII director Rian Johnson will simply continue on and finish up the trilogy. That's certainly an option, and more likely than not we'll be hearing pretty soon about Trevorrow's replacement. As a Star Wars fan I feel that it kind of sucks for the guy, but a small part of me is not terribly sad. I've only seen one of his films (that being Jurassic World), but just given how the characters were handled in that one, I'd kind of rather see someone who can do characters better. I'd throw my hat in for the original Jurassic director, but he's already said he wouldn't do it.
More on this as it develops.
Monday, 4 September 2017
Shin Godzilla Spoiler Free Review
Hey everyone, back again with another review. This time, we’re
looking at a film I’ve been waiting to see for a while now, and finally got the
chance to do so. This week we’re talking Shin Godzilla, the latest
installment of the long-running franchise from Toho Studios. This is in fact
the twenty-ninth film they’ve made for the big guy, and the thirty-first
overall. As usual no spoilers ahead.
This was a fairly highly anticipated in our house. Any new
kaiju movie is, to be honest, but Godzilla… Godzilla is top of that list.
Unfortunately, there wasn’t an opportunity for us to see this film in its limited
North American theatrical run, as the closest place it was showing was four
hours away and we couldn’t make it work. So we’ve waited for home release and
now we’ve finally gotten to see it. I was surprised to see our version was a
dub, also, and not subtitled. And…. I don’t know if it was worth the wait.
Let’s get something out of the way here; this isn’t a terrible
movie. There are some interesting ideas presented and satirized, mainly to
do with the ponderousness of the bureaucratic system and how it can be as much
of a hindrance as a help in an unusual and emergency situation. They really
hammer that point home, too. There is a lot of politics and maneuvering and
people in suits yelling about needing to make decisions.
And that would be a really fascinating study if the story had let you have the time to digest it. This movie flies along at an insane pace. It’s literally boom, boom, boom, with no time to let the previous point sink in before rushing off to the next thing. I’m not entirely sure why the plot needs to rush along so quickly, it’s in such a hurry to get to the end it doesn’t even stop for breath. It was honestly hard to take notes because taking time to write even quick notes made me feel like I was behind.
like this |
And that would be a really fascinating study if the story had let you have the time to digest it. This movie flies along at an insane pace. It’s literally boom, boom, boom, with no time to let the previous point sink in before rushing off to the next thing. I’m not entirely sure why the plot needs to rush along so quickly, it’s in such a hurry to get to the end it doesn’t even stop for breath. It was honestly hard to take notes because taking time to write even quick notes made me feel like I was behind.
I’m not really sure how to talk about the acting. The
Japanese actors seemed to be good physically in their acting. The voice dub
actors were fine, I mean some were better than others but it was overall good.
I wouldn’t mind, if I wanted to watch this again, seeing the Japanese version
to compare the two.
I wonder if in the Japanese version the woman in the left corner still talks like Velma from Scooby Doo. |
The music was interesting, to say the least. They used the
original Gojira theme, which was kind of nice to hear. Not that I think
this Godzilla deserved it, but we’ll get into that later. That wasn’t the only
re-used track, and in fact there were a number of musical callbacks to earlier
films in the Toho universe. There were also a couple of parts where the music
cue shifted quite abruptly into a more rock-guitar thing and seemed really out
of place. It sounds pretty cool just listening to it by itself, but it was such
a weird tonal shift in the film and quite jarring.
One thing I actually really liked was the camera work. There
were some very inventive shots especially when the army was called out and the
tanks were moving into position. I thought that was really well done. It was
shot very much like one would expect a Godzilla movie to look otherwise, but I
really liked what they did. There were also a few with characters using laptops
and a phone that were done in a way I hadn’t seen before and was impressed by.
Okay, last but not least, let’s talk about the big guy
himself. This was a reboot movie, and as such Godzilla got a massive redesign
that while still looking like him, was quite different from what we’ve seen.
Not to get into spoilers, but he had more than one look in the film. I’ll be
honest, I hated the way Godzilla looked. From the first trailer I
thought he looked terrible and that hasn’t changed. He looks more like a zombie
version of himself; like a burned, twisted, undead creature.
I’m not a fan at all, but his final, Godzilla-proper look is miles better than how he looks when he first comes ashore, which is my absolute least favorite.
I’m not sure I like the atomic breath either, it honestly was more like a laser and, without spoilers, went a little too… crazy at times. It felt like they just overdid it. It looked like the arcane enchanted baddies from Diablo III.
I feel like I may have been harder on this movie than I should have been just because Goji looked so damn bad. I get that they were going for something different but the tiny, unblinking eyes and the big, derpy, muppet mouth just didn’t do it for me.
It also seems kind of petty that they made Shin exactly 10.5 meters taller than Legendary’s 2014 Godzilla, as if they had to one-up it. The CG was really inconsistent too, and it’s a good thing they used more than one method to bring Godzilla to life because sometimes it was downright bad. Because this is a reboot he also got a new, updated backstory. I’m not sure I like it, as it changes the symbolism and metaphor of Godzilla to something more updated. I get they wanted to do something different with him and a modern retelling of Godzilla’s origin would have to be something different, but it really feels like they’re fixing something that isn’t broken. He did have a really good roar, at least. According to my more knowledgeable other half, his roars were mainly from the Showa era (encompassing 1954’s Gojira up to 1975’s Terror of Mechagodzilla) except for the last roar which comes from the Heisei era (which began with 1984’s Return of Godzilla and ended with 1995’s Godzilla vs. Destoroyah). There’s also that last shot, which all I’ll say is I don’t like the implications of.
I’m not a fan at all, but his final, Godzilla-proper look is miles better than how he looks when he first comes ashore, which is my absolute least favorite.
I'm only not posting it because spoilers |
I’m not sure I like the atomic breath either, it honestly was more like a laser and, without spoilers, went a little too… crazy at times. It felt like they just overdid it. It looked like the arcane enchanted baddies from Diablo III.
this was all I could think of |
I feel like I may have been harder on this movie than I should have been just because Goji looked so damn bad. I get that they were going for something different but the tiny, unblinking eyes and the big, derpy, muppet mouth just didn’t do it for me.
duurrrrr.... |
It also seems kind of petty that they made Shin exactly 10.5 meters taller than Legendary’s 2014 Godzilla, as if they had to one-up it. The CG was really inconsistent too, and it’s a good thing they used more than one method to bring Godzilla to life because sometimes it was downright bad. Because this is a reboot he also got a new, updated backstory. I’m not sure I like it, as it changes the symbolism and metaphor of Godzilla to something more updated. I get they wanted to do something different with him and a modern retelling of Godzilla’s origin would have to be something different, but it really feels like they’re fixing something that isn’t broken. He did have a really good roar, at least. According to my more knowledgeable other half, his roars were mainly from the Showa era (encompassing 1954’s Gojira up to 1975’s Terror of Mechagodzilla) except for the last roar which comes from the Heisei era (which began with 1984’s Return of Godzilla and ended with 1995’s Godzilla vs. Destoroyah). There’s also that last shot, which all I’ll say is I don’t like the implications of.
So, in conclusion, I wasn’t crazy about this one. It’s not
the worst movie I’ve ever seen, but I wasn’t really feeling it either. This is
a really polarizing movie as well; lots of people loved it and lots of people
hated it. Well, outside of Japan at least, Shin Goji got glowing reviews in his
homeland. If you’re a kaiju or a Godzilla fan, I’d leave it up to you to make
up your own mind on it. Not a fan? I’d skip it because you’d probably find it
boring. At least Toho’s next feature, Godzilla: Planet of theMonsters/Godzilla: Monster Planet looks really intriguing, and I like the
idea of seeing the big guy in animated form for something different.
5/10
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)